The art of thinking · Context card
Cascades: one act on several levels
How can one and the same act be several acts at once?
The short answer
In Alvin Goldman’s theory of action, one doing can generate further acts under the given circumstances: moving a pen writes letters, the letters form a text, the text makes a request. Sebastian Löbner calls such structures cascades and reads them as multilevel categorisation — each level a frame of its own, linked by constitution, not by generality.
For: Information architects, ontology modelers and technical writers
Key points
- Level-generation: under given circumstances, doing one thing amounts to doing another — by moving a hand, a person writes; by writing, the person asks for something.
- A cascade is a tree of such acts; Löbner calls the upward relation c-constitution (constitution under the circumstances).
- Levels of a cascade are levels of constitution, not of generality: they differ from a taxonomy and from a part–whole structure.
- Each level is a frame with its own context, criteria of success and agent role; agents and objects are constituted level by level too.
- Löbner suggests that human categorisation may be multilevel in general: the same occurrence matters in many contexts.
The context
The example of writing
Löbner develops the cascade of writing by hand. At the bottom are three simultaneous acts: holding a pen, pressing it on a surface, moving it along. Together they are writing by hand — producing visible shapes. Under circumstances these shapes are graphemes; the graphemes form a text in a language; the text conveys content; and the content performs an act towards a reader, such as an application, an excuse or a request. Every level has its own context and its own criteria: legibility at the level of graphemes, grammar at the level of text, coherence at the level of content, tone and type of text at the top.
What a cascade is
The structure goes back to Alvin Goldman’s A Theory of Human Action (1970), in which acts generate other acts and form “act-trees”. Löbner calls these trees cascades and the relation between their levels c-constitution. He reads Goldman’s theory as a theory of how people categorise what they do, and combines it with frames: each level is a first-order frame, the cascade relations connect whole frames and are therefore second-order (“hyperframes”).
How it differs from familiar structures
A taxonomy orders concepts from general to specific; a part–whole structure orders things by composition. A cascade orders descriptions of one occurrence by what they amount to in context. In an ontology these are three different relations, and the third is rarely modelled explicitly.
Why it is useful beyond linguistics
The cascade gives words to something every author knows: the same act of writing is judged by different criteria at different levels, and different people care about different levels. It also shows that roles are level-specific — the person with the pen, the author, the partner in an exchange. The encyclopedia article Cascades and level-generation explains the theory in full.
Questions readers ask next
- Is a cascade a hierarchy of categories?
- No. A category hierarchy goes from general to specific. A cascade relates descriptions of one occurrence: the lower act constitutes the higher one under the circumstances.
- Where does the idea come from?
- From Alvin Goldman’s theory of action (1970). Sebastian Löbner reinterpreted it as a theory of categorisation and combined it with frames in his chapter of the volume this card draws on.
- Does every act have several levels?
- Most acts named by verbs do; Goldman also allows basic acts, done without doing anything else. Löbner’s analysis of writing has six levels.
Sources
- Sebastian Löbner et al. (eds.), Concepts, Frames and Cascades in Semantics, Cognition and Ontology (open access, CC BY 4.0) — Springer, 1 January 2021
- Sebastian Löbner, Cascades. Goldman’s Level-Generation, Multilevel Categorization of Action, and Multilevel Verb Semantics (in: Concepts, Frames and Cascades in Semantics, Cognition and Ontology, open access, CC BY 4.0) — Springer, 1 January 2021
- Sebastian Löbner, Thomas Gamerschlag, Tobias Kalenscher, Markus Schrenk and Henk Zeevat, Introduction (in: Concepts, Frames and Cascades in Semantics, Cognition and Ontology, open access, CC BY 4.0) — Springer, 1 January 2021
Review log and changes
Every context card is checked against its sources before it is published, and again whenever it changes; the date under the byline is the last review. Corrections (something was wrong) and additions (something was missing) are logged below with date and time (Berlin time). Typos, formatting and link fixes are not listed.
Reviewed
No corrections or additions since publication.