The art of thinking · Concepts, frames and cascades
Compositionality
Also known as: Principle of compositionality, Frege's principle
German: Kompositionalität
Compositionality is the principle that the meaning of a complex expression is determined by the meanings of its parts and the way they are combined. Usually attributed to Gottlob Frege, it is a working assumption of formal semantics since Richard Montague and is debated for idioms, context-dependent expressions and concept combination.
- Thinking models
- Semantics
- Language
In one sentence
Compositionality: the meaning of a complex expression is determined by the meanings of its parts and their mode of combination.
Example
“Emergency stop button” means a button for the emergency stop function, not a stop button that is an emergency; the mode of combination of the parts decides.
How it applies
- Formal semantics: Montague's grammars assign every syntactic rule a semantic rule, so the meaning of a sentence is computed from its parts.
- The pet-fish problem: Prototypes do not compose simply: a typical pet fish (a goldfish) is neither a typical pet nor a typical fish. The problem, raised by Daniel Osherson and Edward Smith (1981) and used by Jerry Fodor against prototype theories of concepts, is a standing test for theories of concept combination.
- For terminology: Compound terms are rarely transparent. Whether a compound means what its parts suggest has to be stated in its definition, not left to the reader.
Compositionality vs. lexical decomposition
Compositionality concerns how parts combine into larger expressions. Lexical decomposition concerns whether a single word's meaning has parts at all.
External references
How to read this pool
Entries, context cards and transitional topics
The art of thinking explains ways of thinking — where a method comes from, what it asks of you and how it was adapted later. You meet four kinds of content here, each with its own job:
- Glossary entry
- Defines one concept or method of thinking: its origin, an example and how it relates to neighboring ideas. “X vs. Y” sections set two methods side by side.
- Context card of the art of thinking
- A short, self-contained answer to one question about a way of thinking — its lineage, its steps, its limits. These cards are listed on The art of thinking only.
- Transitional topicBridges both pools
- A context card that bridges both pools: it shows how a way of thinking was adapted into documentation, analysis or quality practice. It sits with the reference context cards and is marked as transitional wherever it appears.
- Reference entry or context card
- Belongs to the Glossary & Norms Space on regulation, norms and engineering. Entries here link to one only where a method is also an established tool of documentation or quality work, such as the five whys or a user’s mental model.