The art of thinking · Glossary
Philosophy, reasoning and mental models glossary
Definitions of the methods of thinking and reasoning and where they come from — Aristotle’s first principles and Socrates’ questioning, the axiomatic method, analysis and synthesis, Descartes’ method, first principles thinking and its adaptations in physics, strategy and engineering (first-principles calculations, John Boyd’s destruction and creation, the contrast with reasoning by analogy), and mental models as thinking tools up to Charlie Munger’s latticework. Each entry names its origin and shows what the method looks like in practice; none of them is a norm or a requirement.
Philosophy and logic
First principle (philosophy)
In philosophy and logic, a first principle is a basic proposition or assumption that is not deduced from any other proposition within a system of reasoning and from which further knowledge is derived; Aristotle called such starting points archai.
Thinking models · Philosophy
Definition and examplesSocratic questioning
In philosophy and education, Socratic questioning is a disciplined way of asking systematic questions to examine the definitions, assumptions, evidence and implications behind a claim, named after the Athenian philosopher Socrates (c. 470–399 BCE) as portrayed in Plato’s dialogues.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Problem solving
Definition and examplesAxiomatic method
German: axiomatische Methode
In mathematics and logic, the axiomatic method builds a body of knowledge from a small set of explicitly stated definitions and axioms and derives every further statement from them by proof; Euclid’s Elements (c. 300 BCE) is its classic model and David Hilbert’s Foundations of Geometry (1899) its modern, formal form.
Thinking models · Mathematics
Definition and examplesAnalysis and synthesis (method)
German: Analyse und Synthese
In the history of scientific method, analysis and synthesis is the two-way procedure of resolving a problem or phenomenon into its simpler parts and causes (analysis, resolution) and then reasoning back from them to the whole (synthesis, composition); it runs from Greek geometry, as described by Pappus of Alexandria, through Galileo to Newton.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Engineering
Definition and examplesAbductive reasoning
German: Abduktion
In logic and the philosophy of science, abductive reasoning is inference from an observation to a hypothesis that would, if true, explain it. Charles Sanders Peirce coined the term for a third mode of inference beside deduction and induction, and also called it hypothesis and retroduction; in modern usage it is frequently called inference to the best explanation. An abductive conclusion is never a necessary one: it stays a conjecture until it is tested, and it can be no better than the candidate explanations the reasoner has managed to think of.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Problem solving
Definition and examplesCartesian method
In philosophy, the Cartesian method is the procedure René Descartes set out in his Discourse on the Method (1637): accept nothing as true that is not clearly and distinctly known, divide each difficulty into as many parts as needed, reason in order from the simplest to the most complex, and review everything so that nothing is left out.
Thinking models · Philosophy
Definition and examplesFalsifiability
German: Falsifizierbarkeit
In the philosophy of science, falsifiability is the property of a statement, hypothesis or theory that some logically possible observation would contradict it. Karl Popper introduced it in Logik der Forschung (1934) as his criterion of demarcation between empirical science and non-science: a theory is empirical only if it forbids something that could be observed. Falsifiability is a logical property of the statement, not a verdict on its truth — a falsifiable statement can be true, and it can be well corroborated by tests that failed to refute it.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Problem solving
Definition and examplesInductive reasoning
German: Induktion
In logic and the philosophy of science, inductive reasoning is inference from observed cases to a general rule or to further cases that have not been observed. Its conclusion is ampliative: it says more than the premises contain, so the conclusion can be false even when every premise is true. Inductive arguments are therefore judged by how strongly the evidence supports the conclusion, not by deductive validity, and the justification of this step is the classic problem of induction raised by David Hume.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Problem solving
Definition and examplesNecessary and sufficient conditions
German: notwendige und hinreichende Bedingung
In logic and analytic philosophy, a condition A is necessary for B when B cannot be true without A, and sufficient for B when the truth of A guarantees the truth of B. A condition that is both necessary and sufficient is stated as “B if and only if A” — a biconditional, where the two statements are true together or false together. On the standard account, both relations are read through the material conditional, so that “if A, then B” and “A only if B” express the same thing. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes this standard theory and also records the objections to it, since the English word “if” does not always carry a single kind of condition.
Philosophy · Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesOccam's razor
German: Ockhams Rasiermesser
In philosophy and the philosophy of science, Occam's razor is the principle of parsimony: among competing explanations that account for the evidence equally well, prefer the one that posits the fewest entities or assumptions. It is named after the medieval logician William of Ockham (c. 1287–1347), although the principle is older than he is and the Latin slogans usually quoted are not found in his own texts. It is a cautionary rule for theory choice, not a proof: the leaner explanation is preferred, it is not thereby shown to be true.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Problem solving
Definition and examplesOntology (philosophy)
German: Ontologie (Philosophie)
In philosophy, ontology is the part of metaphysics that asks what there is: which things exist, what the most general kinds or categories of entity are — objects, properties, relations, events, states of affairs — and how entities depend on one another. It also includes the question of how such claims can be settled at all, which is why the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy treats ontology as several related projects rather than one. The word is modern: ontologia appears in Jacob Lorhard's Ogdoas Scholastica of 1606, while the questions go back at least to Aristotle's study of "being qua being". The information-science sense of "ontology" — a machine-readable model of concepts and relations — borrows the name from this tradition but is a different thing.
Philosophy · Thinking models
Definition and examples
First principles thinking and its adaptations
First principles thinking
In problem solving, first principles thinking is the practice of breaking a problem down into the basic facts or assumptions that cannot be reduced any further and reasoning upward from them to a solution, instead of reasoning by analogy with existing solutions or from convention.
Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesFirst-principles calculation
In physics, chemistry and materials science, a first-principles (ab initio) calculation predicts properties of atoms, molecules or materials directly from the fundamental laws of physics — in practice quantum mechanics — without parameters fitted to experimental data for the system being studied.
Thinking models · Engineering · Physics
Definition and examplesDestruction and creation (John Boyd)
In strategic theory, destruction and creation is the mental cycle described by US Air Force Colonel John R. Boyd in his essay of that name (September 3, 1976): existing concepts are broken apart into their constituents (destructive deduction) and the pieces are recombined into a new concept that matches reality better (creative induction).
Thinking models · Strategy · Problem solving
Definition and examplesReasoning by analogy
German: Analogieschluss
In logic and problem solving, reasoning by analogy draws a conclusion about one case from its similarity to another, known case — for example, designing or documenting a new product the way comparable products have been designed or documented.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Problem solving
Definition and examples
Mental models as thinking tools
Mental model (thinking tool)
German: Denkmodell
In the decision-making literature, a mental model is a named, reusable thinking tool — such as first principles thinking, inversion or second-order thinking — that a person applies to understand a problem and decide, as distinct from the cognitive-science sense of a person's internal representation of how something works.
Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesInversion (thinking tool)
As a thinking tool, inversion means approaching a problem from its opposite: instead of asking how to achieve a goal, asking what would guarantee failure, and then avoiding it; the maxim “invert, always invert” is attributed to the mathematician Carl Gustav Jacob Jacobi and was popularized by Charles T. Munger.
Thinking models · Problem solving · Mathematics
Definition and examplesLatticework of mental models
In the decision-making literature, a latticework of mental models is Charlie Munger’s image for a broad set of models from many disciplines that a person combines to understand problems, instead of relying on the models of a single discipline; he set it out in his talk “A Lesson on Elementary, Worldly Wisdom” at the USC Marshall School of Business on April 14, 1994.
Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesPre-mortem
A pre-mortem is a decision technique described by the psychologist Gary Klein in which a team, before a plan is carried out, imagines that it has already failed and writes down every reason why — using prospective hindsight to surface risks that optimism and group pressure hide.
Thinking models · Problem solving · Strategy
Definition and examplesSecond-order thinking
As a thinking tool, second-order thinking means considering not only the immediate effect of a decision but the effects of that effect — how others react, what changes over time, and what is not seen at first.
Thinking models · Problem solving · Strategy
Definition and examples
Reasoning and inference
Concepts, categories and definition
Categories (Aristotle)
In philosophy, Aristotle’s categories are the ten most general kinds of things that can be said about something — substance, quantity, quality, relation, place, time, position, state, action and affection — set out in his treatise Categories.
Thinking models · Philosophy
Definition and examplesEssential and accidental properties
In philosophy, an essential property is one a thing must have to be what it is, and an accidental property is one it happens to have but could lose without ceasing to be that thing.
Thinking models · Philosophy
Definition and examplesFamily resemblance
German: Familienähnlichkeit
In philosophy of language, family resemblance is Ludwig Wittgenstein’s term for concepts whose members are linked by a network of overlapping similarities rather than by one feature they all share; his example is the concept “game”.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Linguistics
Definition and examplesGenus and differentia
German: Genus proximum et differentia specifica
In logic and terminology work, a definition by genus and differentia states what something is by naming the nearest broader class it belongs to (the genus) and the characteristic that sets it apart from the other members of that class (the differentia). The pattern goes back to Aristotle, for whom a correct definition of X gives the genus — what kind of thing X is — and the difference that identifies X uniquely within that genus; the scholastic short form of the rule is "definitio fit per genus proximum et differentiam specificam". Terminology standards use the same structure under a different name: an intensional definition states the immediate superordinate concept plus the delimiting characteristics. The classic textbook example defines a human being as a rational animal, with "animal" as the genus and "rational" as the differentia.
Philosophy · Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesIntension and extension
German: Intension und Extension
In logic and semantics, the intension of a term is its meaning — the properties something must have to fall under it — and its extension is the set of things it actually applies to.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Logic
Definition and examplesType–token distinction
German: Type-Token-Unterscheidung
In philosophy and linguistics, the type–token distinction separates a general kind (the type) from its individual instances (the tokens); the terms were introduced by Charles Sanders Peirce, who noted that a page contains one word “the” as a type but many as tokens.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Linguistics
Definition and examples
Parts, wholes and systems
Cybernetics
German: Kybernetik
Cybernetics is the science of control and communication in animals, machines and organizations — how systems use feedback to pursue goals and stay stable — named and founded as a field by the mathematician Norbert Wiener in 1948.
Thinking models · Systems theory · Engineering
Definition and examplesEmergence
German: Emergenz
In philosophy and systems science, emergence is the appearance of properties or behavior in a whole that none of its parts has on its own and that arise from the way the parts interact.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Systems theory
Definition and examplesGeneral systems theory
German: Allgemeine Systemtheorie
General systems theory is the interdisciplinary study of the principles common to systems of every kind — organisms, machines, organizations — proposed by the biologist Ludwig von Bertalanffy, with the open system that exchanges matter, energy or information with its environment as its central idea.
Thinking models · Systems theory
Definition and examplesLaw of requisite variety
German: Gesetz der erforderlichen Varietät
In cybernetics, the law of requisite variety, formulated by W. Ross Ashby in 1956, states that a regulator can only keep a system’s outcomes within limits if it can produce at least as many distinct responses as there are distinct disturbances to counter — “only variety can destroy variety”.
Thinking models · Systems theory
Definition and examplesMereology
German: Mereologie
In philosophy and formal ontology, mereology is the theory of the relations between parts and wholes — what it means to be part of something, how parts overlap, and when several parts make up a whole.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Logic
Definition and examplesNear-decomposability
In systems theory, near-decomposability is Herbert A. Simon’s term for complex systems built as hierarchies of subsystems in which interactions within a subsystem are much stronger and faster than interactions between subsystems, so that each subsystem can be understood largely on its own.
Thinking models · Systems theory
Definition and examplesSystems thinking
German: Systemdenken
Systems thinking is a way of understanding a situation as a set of interconnected elements whose behavior over time is shaped by feedback loops, stocks, flows and delays, rather than as a chain of isolated causes and effects.
Thinking models · Systems theory · Problem solving
Definition and examples
Knowledge and expertise
Language and meaning
Cooperative principle
German: Kooperationsprinzip
In pragmatics, the cooperative principle is H. Paul Grice’s description of how conversation works: speakers are expected to make their contribution such as is required, at the stage at which it occurs, by the accepted purpose of the exchange — spelled out in the maxims of quantity, quality, relation and manner.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Linguistics
Definition and examplesGenre as social action
In rhetoric and writing studies, genre as social action is Carolyn R. Miller’s view that a genre is not defined by its form but by the typified action it performs in a recurring situation — a recall notice, a work order or an instruction manual is recognized by what it does.
Thinking models · Rhetoric
Definition and examplesRhetorical situation
German: rhetorische Situation
In rhetoric, the rhetorical situation is Lloyd F. Bitzer’s term for the context that calls for discourse: an exigence (a problem that communication can help resolve), an audience able to act on it, and the constraints that shape what can be said.
Thinking models · Rhetoric
Definition and examplesSpeech act theory
German: Sprechakttheorie
In philosophy of language, speech act theory holds that utterances are actions — stating, ordering, promising, warning — and analyzes what a speaker does in saying something; it was founded by J. L. Austin and systematized by John R. Searle.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Linguistics
Definition and examplesVagueness and ambiguity
German: Vagheit und Mehrdeutigkeit
In philosophy of language and linguistics, an expression is vague when it has borderline cases to which it neither clearly applies nor clearly fails to apply, and ambiguous when it has two or more distinct meanings.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Linguistics
Definition and examples
Mind and moral status
Biological naturalism
German: Biologischer Naturalismus
In philosophy of mind, biological naturalism is John Searle's position that consciousness is a real biological phenomenon caused by processes in the brain, so that running a computer program, however sophisticated, is not by itself sufficient for consciousness.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Philosophy of mind
Definition and examplesComputational functionalism
In philosophy of mind, computational functionalism is the position that performing computations of the right kind is sufficient for having mental states, including consciousness, whatever the physical substrate that performs them.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Philosophy of mind
Definition and examplesMoral patient
In moral philosophy, a moral patient is a being whose interests count morally for its own sake, so that what is done to it can wrong it; a moral agent, by contrast, is a being that can act morally and be held responsible for what it does.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Ethics
Definition and examples
Thinking in practice
Deliberate practice
German: Gezieltes Üben
In research on expertise, deliberate practice is effortful activity designed specifically to improve performance, usually with clear goals, immediate feedback and repetition at the edge of one’s ability; K. Anders Ericsson, Ralf Th. Krampe and Clemens Tesch-Römer introduced the concept in 1993.
Thinking models · Learning
Definition and examplesDivergent and convergent thinking
German: Divergentes und konvergentes Denken
In the psychology of thinking, divergent thinking generates many possible answers to an open question, and convergent thinking narrows possibilities down to the one answer that fits; J. P. Guilford introduced the distinction as divergent and convergent production in his work on creativity and the structure of intellect (1950, 1956).
Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesImplementation intention
German: Durchführungsintention
In motivation psychology, an implementation intention is a plan of the form “If situation X arises, then I will do Y”, which links a goal to a specific situation and response; Peter M. Gollwitzer described the concept and its effects in 1999.
Thinking models · Learning
Definition and examplesIncubation (problem solving)
German: Inkubation
In the psychology of thinking, incubation is the phase in which a problem is set aside after initial work before it is taken up again; Graham Wallas named it in The Art of Thought (1926) as the second of four stages of creative thought — preparation, incubation, illumination and verification.
Thinking models · Problem solving
Definition and examplesZettelkasten
German: Zettelkasten
A Zettelkasten is a card index of notes in which every note has a fixed address and links to other notes, so that ideas can be filed, found and connected over many years; the sociologist Niklas Luhmann kept the best-known example, about 90,000 notes written between 1951 and 1996, and described it as a partner in communication.
Thinking models · Knowledge management
Definition and examples
Concepts, frames and cascades
Frame (concept representation)
German: Frame (Begriffsrepräsentation)
In cognitive science and semantics, a frame is a recursive attribute–value structure that represents a concept: a central node for the thing described, functional attributes such as color or owner, values that can themselves be frames, and constraints between the values. Lawrence W. Barsalou proposed in 1992 that human concepts have this format.
Thinking models · Concepts · Semantics
Definition and examplesAttribute–value structure
German: Attribut-Wert-Struktur
An attribute–value structure is a representation that describes an object as a set of attributes, each paired with a value that may itself be an attribute–value structure. Written as an attribute–value matrix (AVM), it is used for frames in semantics, for feature structures in computational linguistics and in knowledge representation.
Thinking models · Concepts · Semantics
Definition and examplesFrame semantics (Fillmore)
German: Frame-Semantik
Frame semantics is the approach in linguistics, developed by Charles J. Fillmore from the 1970s, in which the meaning of a word is understood against a frame: a schematic representation of a situation type with its participants and props. A word evokes its frame, and understanding the word requires knowing the frame.
Thinking models · Semantics · Language
Definition and examplesLevel-generation
German: Level-Generation
In Alvin Goldman's theory of human action (1970), level-generation is the relation in which one act, under given circumstances, generates another act done by the same agent at the same time: flipping the switch generates turning on the light. Goldman distinguishes causal, conventional, simple and augmentation generation and draws the result as an act-tree.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Action
Definition and examplesCascade (frame theory)
German: Kaskade (Frame-Theorie)
In Sebastian Löbner's frame theory, a cascade is a structure of act-types on several levels in which an act of a lower level constitutes an act of a higher level under given circumstances. Löbner models it as a second-order frame (a hyperframe) that links first-order frames of the single acts, and uses it to describe multilevel categorization and the meaning of action verbs.
Thinking models · Concepts · Action
Definition and examplesConceptual space
German: Konzeptueller Raum
In Peter Gärdenfors' theory (2000), a conceptual space is a geometric representation of concepts built from quality dimensions such as hue, size or temperature, grouped into domains. Objects are points, similarity is distance and natural properties are convex regions of a domain; a concept combines regions of several domains.
Thinking models · Concepts · Semantics
Definition and examplesCompositionality
German: Kompositionalität
Compositionality is the principle that the meaning of a complex expression is determined by the meanings of its parts and the way they are combined. Usually attributed to Gottlob Frege, it is a working assumption of formal semantics since Richard Montague and is debated for idioms, context-dependent expressions and concept combination.
Thinking models · Semantics · Language
Definition and examplesFormal semantics
German: Formale Semantik
Formal semantics is the study of meaning in natural language with the tools of logic and model theory: the meaning of a sentence is given by its truth conditions relative to a model, often with possible worlds, and is built compositionally from the meanings of its parts. Its modern form goes back to Richard Montague's work around 1970.
Thinking models · Semantics · Logic
Definition and examplesType Theory with Records (TTR)
German: Type Theory with Records (TTR)
Type Theory with Records (TTR) is a rich type theory for natural-language semantics developed by Robin Cooper, in which meanings are types and situations are records: structures of labeled fields whose values belong to types. Record types can model frames, so TTR connects formal semantics with frame-based and perceptual accounts of meaning.
Thinking models · Semantics · Logic
Definition and examplesLexical decomposition
German: Lexikalische Dekomposition
Lexical decomposition is the analysis of a word's meaning into smaller components — semantic features, primitive predicates such as CAUSE and BECOME, or the attributes of a frame. It assumes that word meanings have internal structure that explains their inferences, and is opposed by conceptual atomism.
Thinking models · Semantics · Concepts
Definition and examplesConceptual atomism
German: Begriffsatomismus
Conceptual atomism is the position, defended above all by Jerry Fodor, that most lexical concepts have no internal structure: the concept DOG is not composed of features or a definition but is a primitive symbol whose content comes from its relation to dogs. It is a philosophical position, opposed by decompositional, prototype and frame theories.
Thinking models · Philosophy · Concepts
Definition and examplesAnalytic–synthetic distinction
German: Unterscheidung analytisch–synthetisch
The analytic–synthetic distinction separates statements true by virtue of their meaning alone (analytic: “all bachelors are unmarried”) from statements whose truth also depends on how the world is (synthetic). Introduced in this form by Immanuel Kant, it was famously challenged by W. V. O. Quine in “Two Dogmas of Empiricism” (1951).
Thinking models · Philosophy · Logic
Definition and examples
How to read this pool
Entries, context cards and transitional topics
The art of thinking explains ways of thinking — where a method comes from, what it asks of you and how it was adapted later. You meet four kinds of content here, each with its own job:
- Glossary entry
- Defines one concept or method of thinking: its origin, an example and how it relates to neighboring ideas. “X vs. Y” sections set two methods side by side.
- Context card of the art of thinking
- A short, self-contained answer to one question about a way of thinking — its lineage, its steps, its limits. These cards are listed on The art of thinking only.
- Transitional topicBridges both pools
- A context card that bridges both pools: it shows how a way of thinking was adapted into documentation, analysis or quality practice. It sits with the reference context cards and is marked as transitional wherever it appears.
- Reference entry or context card
- Belongs to the Glossary & Norms Space on regulation, norms and engineering. Entries here link to one only where a method is also an established tool of documentation or quality work, such as the five whys or a user’s mental model.
Definitions follow the cited philosophical and historical sources — primary texts, their standard translations and reference works such as the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy — and, for cognitive psychology, the published research and its reviews, with the state of the evidence named in each entry. They are paraphrased, not quoted, unless a passage is marked as a quotation, and sayings that cannot be traced to a source stay attributed. Examples, comparisons and the notes on how a method was adapted are editorial commentary by knowledge.aitechdoc.world. None of these entries is a norm, a standard or a legal requirement, and applying one never replaces a method that a standard or a law requires.