Concepts, frames and cascades
Formal and cognitive semantics
Also known as: Model-theoretic semantics · Montague semantics · Type Theory with Records · Cognitive approaches to meaning
Formal semantics analyzes meaning through truth conditions and logical relations, in the tradition of Richard Montague; cognitive approaches model meanings as concepts in the mind. The introduction to *Concepts, Frames and Cascades* traces how the two diverged and where they meet again — in richer model ontologies, in agents with an epistemic perspective and in type theories that can model frames.
By knowledge.aitechdoc.world · Last reviewed
Definition
Formal semantics assigns to sentences truth conditions relative to models, typically possible worlds, and derives the meaning of a complex expression from the meanings of its parts and the way they are combined (the principle of compositionality). Its adequacy criterion is logical: an analysis should account for the entailments of a sentence. Cognitive semantics treats meanings as conceptual structures stored or formed in the mind and asks for psychological adequacy.
Historical development
Gottlob Frege distinguished sense and reference (1892) and formulated compositionality. Rudolf Carnap, Alfred Tarski and Donald Davidson developed intensions, truth definitions and truth-conditional semantics for natural language. Richard Montague (1970, 1973) treated the syntax and semantics of natural language as branches of mathematics. The introduction to the volume describes this as an extensional turn: Frege’s sense was reconstructed as a set-theoretic intension, which made it hard to connect semantics to cognitive science. Lexical meaning remained largely unanalyzed, with exceptions such as Dowty and Pustejovsky.
Main positions in the volume
- Agents and perspective. Kristina Liefke proposes a parametrized notion of content, with parameters for agents, times and information states, that explains why expressions can be substituted in extensional but not in attitude contexts.
- Richer ontologies. Manfred Krifka analyzes the counting of objects that overlap, such as outfits that share pieces of clothing, as individual concepts. Marcin Morzycki argues that adjectives such as average and occasional are about kinds and have the semantic type of quantifiers.
- Types as concepts. Robin Cooper presents perception as classification by types in TTR, a Type Theory with Records, and proposes record types as a formal model of frames in the sense of Fillmore, Barsalou and the Düsseldorf approach.
- Context and perspective in use. Martín Fuchs, María Mercedes Piñango and Ashwini Deo explain variation between Spanish aspect markers by perspective alignment between speaker and hearer, balancing theory of mind and common ground.
Function and purpose
The comparison clarifies what a semantic analysis is for. A truth-conditional analysis says when a sentence is true and what follows from it; a conceptual analysis says what a speaker represents. Sentences with the same truth conditions, such as different mathematical truths, can differ in conceptual content.
Relevance to knowledge representation
Description logics and RDF-based ontologies inherit the model-theoretic tradition: classes are sets, properties relations, and reasoning is entailment. Frames and record types add structure that set theory leaves implicit. The bridge Cooper proposes — types that are both logical objects and cognitive resources — is close to how typed schemas are used in practice.
Conclusion
Formal and cognitive semantics answer different questions about meaning. The volume shows them converging: formal analyses introduce agents, perspectives and finer ontologies, and frame theories gain formal definitions.
Source work and licence
This article draws on:
- Sebastian Löbner, Thomas Gamerschlag, Tobias Kalenscher, Markus Schrenk, Henk Zeevat: “Introduction”, pp. 1 ff.. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3_1
- Kristina Liefke: “A Compositional Pluralist Semantics for Extensional and Attitude Verbs”, pp. 25 ff.. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3_2
- Manfred Krifka: “Counting Possible Configurations”, pp. 43 ff.. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3_3
- Marcin Morzycki: “Structure and Ontology in Nonlocal Readings of Adjectives”, pp. 65 ff.. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3_4
- Robin Cooper: “Perception, Types and Frames”, pp. 165 ff.. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3_8
- Martín Fuchs, María Mercedes Piñango, Ashwini Deo: “Operationalizing the Role of Context in Language Variation: The Role of Perspective Alignment in the Spanish Imperfective Domain”, pp. 201 ff.. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3_10
In:
Sebastian Löbner, Thomas Gamerschlag, Tobias Kalenscher, Markus Schrenk, Henk Zeevat (eds.), Concepts, Frames and Cascades in Semantics, Cognition and Ontology. Language, Cognition, and Mind, vol. 7. Springer (Springer Nature Switzerland AG), 2021. ISBN 978-3-030-50200-3. doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-50200-3
Open access under the CC BY 4.0 licence. The articles of this subject area summarize, compare and recontextualize the volume’s ideas in our own words and structure; no text, figures or tables are reproduced. Positions are attributed to the chapter authors; the comparisons and the relation to ontologies and documentation are ours.
Further reading
- Concepts, Frames and Cascades in Semantics, Cognition and Ontology (open access, CC BY 4.0) — Springer
- Montague Semantics — Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
Cite this article
knowledge.aitechdoc.world. “Formal and cognitive semantics.” Encyclopedia, AI TechDoc Knowledge. Last reviewed October 13, 2026. https://knowledge.aitechdoc.world/encyclopedia/concepts-frames-and-cascades/formal-and-cognitive-semantics